West Shore Inn Steakhouse

The filet was cooked to perfection! The loaded mashed potatoes were great. The vegetables were a little bland.
The blue moon on draft was excellent! Great friendly service with a smile. These city folks made this country boy feel right at home! Definitely recommend this place for a great steak!

Was pleasantly surprised by this place. To be honest wasn't expecting much at first but the food and service was great. Think it is a little bit pricier than it needs to be (steaks and pastas) but there are more affordable menu options as well. From the drinks to the food, very happy! Especially recommend the white sangria, calamari and tiramasu. It has an old steak house look to it so you will be very surprised by the modern and updated bathrooms. Would return in the future.

Beyond happy with our experience! I started with a bees knees and highly recommend doing the same. Then we split some very delicious French onion soup. For our mains we both got the NY strip (medium rare) with herb butter, veggies and mashed potatoes. Easy to say we cleared both plates!!

The West Shore Inn is my family's number one go-to spot on Staten Island. Somehow, even with such a diverse menu, everything is always delicious. It may be a steakhouse but they specialize in so much more. I'm particularly a fan of their penne vodka and honestly writing this review right now is making me want to go back and get an order of that pasta right now. It is a bar as well as a restaurant and it has the feel of a pub you might walk into in the English countryside. The staff are always very nice and even though most times there is a bit of a wait for a table it's worth it, believe me. I definitely recommend having dinner here if you get the chance to!